Congratulations Alex Vincent, March 2024 PFRE Photographer of the Month! The theme this month was "Kitchen". Alex Vincent - #906 Yvonne Raaijmakers - #909 Peter Wingfield - #902 Here's what Alex has to say: Thank you for the award of Photographer of th ...
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Both Photoshop and Capture One are high-end photo editing applications that real estate photographers use to edit and organize their images. Let us explore the Capture One vs Photoshop strengths and weaknesses that determine their ideal application conditions.
Quick Navigation
Although it is possible to carry out almost similar photo edits, comparing Capture One vs Photoshop is the best way to understand their capability and performance variations. They are distinct photo editing applications from different developers and come with different styles and organizational features.
Capture One is a high-end photo editing software with a good reputation for tether optimization, easily navigable tools, and camera presets. It is also a versatile photo management application with easy-to-use features for amateur and professional photographers.
Capture One is developed and owned by phase-one, a camera manufacturing company in Denmark. It is non-destructive editing software primarily designed to handle and process RAW files and then export the finished versions.
Typically, the design of Capture One is almost similar to that of Lightroom or the Camera RAW in Photoshop. That means the following Capture One color, layer, and masking tools are advanced and powerful, making them ideal for professional real estate photographers.
Photoshop is a product of Adobe and is currently the most popular photo editing and graphic creation application in the market. Photoshop is versatile and comes with advanced features that you can use to create even the most complex graphics.
Unlike Capture One, Photoshop is primarily designed for photo manipulation across different disciplines such as
Typically, you can use Photoshop to create or improve paintings, three-dimensional artworks, and illustrations. Photoshop features and tools can create posters, banners, icons, websites, and mobile applications.
In most cases, you will need to edit your real estate photos before posting online, printing, or storing them in digital format. Understanding how Capture One compares with Photoshop will help you determine which application will suit your photo-editing needs best.
Both Photoshop and Capture One are advanced photo editing applications that you can use in image processing, photo editing, and exporting images in different file formats. They share the following similarities in their design and features.
Although Capture One and Photoshop are streamlined image processing and management applications, they have differences in their design, features, RAW file processing, and editing capability.
Layers refer to the different levels of transparency that you can apply to a digital image when editing. They allow you to work on images in a stacking manner and apply different image effects without mixing the pixels. That means you can separately work on different elements of a digital image.
In Capture One, the layers are located in the exposure tab under the histogram. You can add a layer by clicking on the plus sign in the layers panel. Typically, Capture One allows you to work with up to 16 layers associated with one photo.
On the other hand, you can create a new layer in Photoshop by clicking on the new layer button located in the layers panel. You can also create a new layer and change its default name and options. Photoshop allows you to make up to 8,000 layers with different opacity and blending modes.
The Liquify tool is a tool that helps you distort certain regions of a photo without interfering with the quality. Typically, you can use the liquify tool to bloat, pucker, pull, or push specific pixels of an image.
Adobe Photoshop comes with an advanced liquify tool with advanced face-detection intelligence that makes it user-friendly.
On the other hand, Capture One doesn't feature this tool. Typically, Capture One is not more of a pixel editor like Adobe Photoshop. That means if you want to push back something sticking out or narrow something too wide in your real estate photo, then go for Photoshop.
A RAW is an image directly from the camera that contains uncompressed and unprocessed grayscale image data with additional information on how the photo was shot. The photo editing software then uses this data to create and process a color picture.
Since Capture One is designed for image processing, its RAW image conversion is true-to-life color processing. It also comes with more than 500 custom camera profiles. Additionally, the RAW file processing takes place in the same window, and you don't have to go back to the camera RAW to see the settings.
On the other hand, Photoshop is designed with powerful photo-editing tools more than its RAW image processing performance. Although it is possible to adjust aspects such as sharpening, color saturation, contrast, tonal range, and white balance in Photoshop, it can't match the RAW file processing in Capture One.
The user interface refers to the point you will be interacting with the photo editing software. It consists of how the different tools, features, and panels are arranged and how straightforward it is to use them. Usually, a complex user interface makes the application complicated to set up and use, especially for beginners.
The Capture One user interface is customizable and flexible, allowing beginners to set up the screen without hassle. The user interface elements include an image browser, a viewer, cursor tools, and a tool tab bar. You can customize these elements to appear the way you want on the screen.
Photoshop comes with many industry-standard photo editing and creative features for professional photographers, making the user interface more complicated. However, this interface is consistent with the other Adobe applications, such as Illustrator and InDesign, so you should have no problem using it if you are familiar with the other Adobe applications.
How much time it will take to edit one photo is a key factor to consider, especially if you're working on tons of images. The overall speed of photo editing will depend on how fast you can apply the edits and how smooth the application can run on your computer without jitters.
Keeping in mind that Capture One is more lightweight than Photoshop, it runs faster on both the PC and Mac platforms. On the other hand, Photoshop maximizes your image's space and minimizes the space for the tools, making it challenging to locate some of the basic tools.
As a result, it becomes easier and faster to carry out basic photo edits such as dynamic range, contrast, and white balance using Capture One, especially if you have a large collection of photos.
Retouching means getting rid of imperfections from an image. Some of the imperfections that you might want to work on may include tone and color correction, under-eye and blemishes remover, saturation and contrast improvements, or a change of brightness.
Usually, retouching is all about improving the look and style of the image. Although Capture One comes with some retouching tools such as gradient filters, plus radial and healing brush and cloning, it can't match some of the complex retouching tools in Photoshop.
For instance, Photoshop comes with a content-aware tool that can automatically detect and fill the background of an image. You can also use Photoshop to blur the background and bring the main subject into focus.
Presets refer to saved photo editing settings, and you can apply them to an image at the click of a button. On the other hand, plugins are additional programmed features that you can install into the photo editing application to boost productivity.
Typically, you can use presets and plugins to copy other professional photographers' styles in their photo editing. Photoshop is an industry-standard and has been in the market for longer, so it has more presets and plugins than Capture One.
Tethered shooting involves connecting the camera to the computer with the photo editing software running, allowing you to view the images live as you shoot. This connection helps to keep the workflow seamless and efficient when shooting.
Capture One features the tethered capture option, allowing you to view the images live as you shoot. Typically, this allows you to use the Capture One software to control the camera and apply live edits if necessary. On the other hand, Photoshop doesn't support tethered shooting.
Image organization is one of the key features you will want to consider in any photo editing software, especially if you're working with many images. Capture One allows you to organize and access images in the form of catalogs and sessions.
Capture One allows you to organize and edit the pictures from the same screen. This photo organization helps to improve the overall speed of the workflow.
On the other hand, Photoshop is generally designed for use with one image at a time. Although there are certain photo-specific features, Photoshop uses Adobe Bridge, which looks similar to the file explorer you can find on any Mac or Windows PC.
In most cases, you will want a photo editing software to connect with other applications for additional image processing or sharing options. Although Capture One has some plugins that you can use to connect it with other applications, it's still more of an independent piece of software.
On the other hand, Photoshop can integrate and connect well with other applications, especially other Adobe products. Photoshop is a part of Adobe's Creative Cloud, so you can even access images directly into Photoshop from the Adobe stock services.
The color control in Capture One is intuitive and straightforward, thanks to the three color pickers. It comes with skin tone settings that make changing the color balance easy even for beginners.
On the other hand, Photoshop color control is more complex and contains elements that a typical real estate photographer might not need. Therefore, the capture One color control is preferable even to professionals who want to speed up their workflow.
The photo editing software supporting a camera is important, especially for color accuracy during RAW file processing. Although Photoshop is versatile and supports all camera models, it doesn't feature specific profiles for specific models.
On the other hand, Capture One comes with a specific profile for specific cameras such as Nikon, Sony, and Fujifilm. The specific support for these models gives you an edge when editing images, whether JPGs or RAW files.
Although many people believe that the use-of-use of a photo editing application is all about the user interface, it involves the learning curve and the available user guides. The arrangement and streamlining of features is also a key factor.
Although Photoshop has been in the market for longer and has many online tutorials, the many complex features and tools in Photoshop combined with the different ways of doing stuff in Photoshop can be confusing, especially for beginners.
The photo editing experience is more straightforward in Capture One than in Photoshop, thanks to streamlining features and step-by-step guides.
Although Capture One and Photoshop come with a trial period and subscription plans, they vary in their offerings. For instance, Capture One comes with a 30-day free trial, while Photoshop comes with a 7-day free trial.
When it comes to the subscription terms, Capture One doesn't allow you to cancel a subscription before the contract period ends, whether it is monthly or annually. That means Capture One doesn't refund if you want to cancel a subscription.
On the other hand, Photoshop allows you to cancel the subscription at any time. If you cancel the subscription before 14 days, you will be refunded. However, if you cancel the subscription after 14 days, there will be no refund, whether it is a monthly or annual subscription.
Capture One and Photoshop vary on the minimum system requirements depending on the operating system you are using. For instance, if you are using Mac, your system needs to have the following minimum requirements for it to run Capture One:
Note that Capture One doesn't support Mac OS versions later than version 12.1. On the other hand, your system needs to meet the following requirements to run Photoshop in Mac:
If you use a Windows PC, your system should meet the following requirements for you to run Capture One:
Note that Capture One supports Windows 10 builds 1607 to version 21H2. On the other hand, your Windows PC will need to have the following minimum requirements for you to run Photoshop:
Note that the above are the minimum requirements and not the recommended requirements. That means for the best photo editing experience, go for a system with a higher performance than this. If you'd like to run your Capture One Live, you will also need an internet connection.
The major distinguishing factor between Capture One and Photoshop is their pricing plan. Capture One offers three packages: a monthly subscription, yearly subscription, or a one-time payment to own the Capture One license.
The monthly subscription goes for $24, the annual subscription costs $179 a year, and the one-time payment license costs $299. On the other hand, Photoshop allows you to subscribe to the Adobe Creative Cloud using varying pricing plans.
Subscribing to the Creative Cloud
Although you can use both Photoshop and Capture One to process, edit and manage photos, the versatility and ease of use of Capture One make it suitable for use in the following circumstances.
Photoshop is an industry-standard photo editing software with complex features that suits professional photographers and designers, making it have benefits over Capture One in the following situations.
Considering that Photoshop is more of an image manipulator and Capture One is more of a RAW editor, it can be challenging to determine which one is better than the other. Typically, Photoshop is better when carrying out complex photo edits, such as blending multiple exposures or retouching.
On the other hand, Capture One is better for RAW file processing and image organization. That means you can use Photoshop and Capture One as complementary applications.
Both Capture One and Photoshop are versatile photo editing applications that you can use in all stages of image processing, editing, and organization. The easy-to-use Capture One interface makes it ideal for beginners, while the high-end retouching features in Photoshop make it ideal for professionals.
